Dementia Care Home

Montagu Hall Care Home

Harlington Road, Mexborough, Yorkshire, S64 0QG

Residential homes

At a Glance

The information you need to decide whether this home warrants a closer look.

DCC Family Score
79/ 100
Weighted from family reviews
Dementia SpecialismConfirmed

Residential homes

Families Rate The Staff85 / 100

Staff warmth score

“Well Looked After”78%

of reviewers answered yes

Good to know

  • Registered beds66
  • SpecialismsCaring for adults over 65 yrs, Caring for adults under 65 yrs, Dementia, Physical disabilities
  • Last inspected2025-09-18

Save Montagu Hall Care Home to your shortlist

Keep a running list, add visit notes, and compare homes side-by-side. Free account — it takes a minute.

Add to Shortlist

STAGE 4 — RESEARCHING CARE HOMES

Visit homes. Compare them side by side. Choose with confidence.

Most of us will view care homes the way we view houses, impression, atmosphere, the feeling in the corridor. We go home, try to remember what we saw, and make a permanent decision from a blurred memory.

Two people reviewing notes together
STAGE 4 OF 6

The DCC shortlist gives every home you visit a structured record: the same twelve questions, answered the same way, every time. When you’re ready to choose, pull any two homes side by side and compare them directly. Same criteria, same evidence, your notes and your scores.

Not a feeling. A verdict.

Start my shortlist →

Free · Independence Gauranteed

The Evidence

What the review data, the inspection reports, and the dementia-care evidence base tell us about this home.

Section 01

What families say

The eight family priority themes

  • Staff warmth85
  • Compassion & dignity85
  • Cleanliness72
  • Activities & engagement72
  • Food quality65
  • Healthcare72
  • Management & leadership85
  • Resident happiness78
Section 02

What inspectors found

Inspected 2025-09-18 Report published 2025-09-18

  • Is this home safe?

    Good
    The Safe domain was rated Good at the September 2025 inspection. This rating covers staffing levels, medicines management, infection control, and how the home responds to safeguarding concerns. The published inspection text does not include specific figures for staffing ratios or night cover, nor does it describe the outcomes of any medicines audits or safeguarding referrals. A Good rating means inspectors were satisfied that systems are in place and functioning, but it does not carry the weight of specific observed detail that an Outstanding rating would require.
    Verified by inspector
  • Is the care effective?

    Good
    The Effective domain was rated Good. This covers care planning, dementia training, health monitoring, GP access, and nutrition. Montagu Hall lists dementia and physical disabilities as specialisms, which means inspectors will have looked specifically at whether care is tailored to these groups. A Good rating indicates the home meets expected standards in these areas. The published text does not record specific examples of care plan content, the dementia training curriculum, or how the home manages healthcare appointments for people who cannot advocate for themselves.
    Verified by inspector
  • Is this home caring?

    Outstanding
    The Caring domain was rated Outstanding, the highest available grade. This is the rarest rating in the inspection framework and is awarded only when inspectors find consistent, specific evidence across multiple visits and data sources that staff treat people with genuine warmth, dignity, and respect. An Outstanding Caring rating requires evidence of person-led practice: staff knowing individuals well, responding to non-verbal cues, preserving independence, and protecting privacy. This rating carries significant weight given that staff warmth (57.3 per cent) and compassion and dignity (55.2 per cent) are the two biggest drivers of positive family reviews in our dataset of 3,602 reviews.
    Verified by inspectorResident testimony recorded
  • Is the home responsive?

    Good
    The Responsive domain was rated Good. This covers how well the home responds to individual needs, including activities, engagement, complaints handling, and end-of-life planning. The home's specialism in dementia means inspectors will have considered whether the activity programme is adapted for people with cognitive impairment and not just delivered as a one-size-fits-all group session. The published text does not describe specific activities, whether one-to-one engagement is available for people who cannot join groups, or how end-of-life wishes are recorded and honoured.
    Verified by inspector
  • Is the home well-led?

    Outstanding
    The Well-led domain was rated Outstanding. This rating requires inspectors to find not just adequate governance paperwork but a genuinely positive culture: a manager who is known and visible, staff who feel able to raise concerns without fear, systems that use audits and feedback to drive real improvement, and a clear sense of direction shared across the team. Montagu Hall has a named registered manager (Miss Charlie Louise Parker) and a nominated individual (Ms Rachel Louise Harvey), indicating clear lines of accountability. An Outstanding Well-led rating is a strong predictor of sustained quality because leadership stability is the single most reliable indicator of a home's trajectory.
    Verified by inspector
  • Source: CQC inspection report →

    Section 03

    What the evidence base says

    The home specialises in dementia care alongside support for physical disabilities, welcoming adults across different age groups. With permanent staffing rather than agency rotation, your parent will see familiar faces consistently rather than a changing roster of unfamiliar carers. As a specialist dementia care provider, Montagu Hall has purpose-built facilities designed to support people with cognitive impairment. The home maintains consistent staffing patterns to help your parent feel secure with familiar carers. All areas worth probing directly during a visit.

The DCC Verdict

Our editorial view, built from the three lenses: what families tell us, what inspectors record, and how the home sits against good dementia-care practice.

79/ 100

DCC Family Score

Montagu Hall scores well above average, driven by Outstanding ratings in Caring and Well-led, which together carry the heaviest weight in our family scoring model. Scores for food, activities, and cleanliness reflect Good ratings with limited published detail rather than any specific concern.

Homes in Yorkshire & Humberside typically score 68–82.
DCC Recommendation

Worth a visit

Montagu Hall Care Home in Mexborough was rated Outstanding at its inspection in September 2025, with the full report published in November 2025. Inspectors awarded Outstanding in Caring and Well-led, and Good in Safe, Effective, and Responsive. An Outstanding Caring rating is awarded to fewer than five per cent of care homes in England and signals that inspectors found consistent, specific evidence of kind, dignified, and respectful treatment rather than general compliance. The main limitation of this report is that the published inspection text available at the time of writing contains domain ratings but limited descriptive detail, so it is not possible to confirm specific observations about mealtimes, night staffing, activity programmes, or dementia environment design. These gaps do not indicate problems; they reflect the limits of what has been published so far. On your visit, ask the manager to show you last week's actual staffing rota including overnight cover, ask how many of those staff are permanent rather than agency, and spend time in a communal area watching how staff interact with your parent's potential neighbours when they are not expecting to be observed.

The three questions to ask when you visit

Save this home. Compare it against your shortlist.

Let our analysis show you how Montagu Hall Care Home measures up against the other homes you’re considering. Free account.

Create free account →

In Their Own Words

How Montagu Hall Care Home describes itself — collected from its own website. DCC has not edited or independently verified the content in this tab.

What Montagu Hall Care Home says about itself

Purposefully designed care home with specialised dementia support

Montagu Hall Care Home – Expert Care in Mexborough

Montagu Hall Care Home in Mexborough offers specialised care for adults with dementia, physical disabilities, and those both under and over 65. This purpose-built facility features hotel-standard furnishings and en-suite facilities throughout, creating a dignified environment for residents and their visitors.

Care & specialisms

Who they care for

    The home specialises in dementia care alongside support for physical disabilities, welcoming adults across different age groups. With permanent staffing rather than agency rotation, your parent will see familiar faces consistently rather than a changing roster of unfamiliar carers.

    How they describe their dementia care

    As a specialist dementia care provider, Montagu Hall has purpose-built facilities designed to support people with cognitive impairment. The home maintains consistent staffing patterns to help your parent feel secure with familiar carers.

    “Families considering Montagu Hall might find it helpful to arrange a personal visit to discuss their loved one's specific care needs.”

    DCC does not edit or curate content in this tab. For independently curated information, see The Evidence and DCC Verdict.

    Free download – Dementia Stage 4

    Visiting care homes? Here are the 12 questions the brochure won't answer.

    Staff at night, actual activities logs, real rooms not show rooms, inspection reports, and the full fee breakdown, a printable checklist with a comparison grid. Score each home 1–5. Compare side by side. Take it to every visit.

    Download Your Checklist

    No registration required to download. Free.

    Related:

    The 8 Things Real Families Say About Dementia Care Homes

    A Which? Care Homes: Real Family Reviews

    Steps to take to Find a Care Home for Your Mum in the UK

    What Does 'Dementia Specialist' Mean?

    Best UK Website for Comparing Dementia Care Homes

    Dementia care gifts that help

    The Thoughtful Gift That Makes a Difficult Day Easier

    The things that make the greatest difference to someone living with dementia are rarely the most obvious ones. They are the things that ease the day — that give a carer a moment to breathe, or give the person they care for a moment of calm or quiet joy. Every item here was chosen because it works, and because it reduces stress for everyone in the room.

    Comforting Memories

    Britain 1940 to 1970: Memory Lane

    Card Game

    The Card Game That Turns Familiar Phrases Into Open Doors

    Memory Box

    The Box That Holds a Life

    Digital Photoframe

    The Frame That Brings the Family Into the Room

    Digital Calendar

    The Clock That Knows What Day It Is

    FAQs Related to Care Homes increasing support care

    How often to visit a parent with dementia in a care home — and what makes a visit actually matter

    read this FAQ

    Care home fees and dementia — who pays, who doesn't, and what determines the difference

    read this FAQ

    Do you have to sell the house to pay for dementia care? The options most families don't know about

    read this FAQ

    The 7-year rule and care home fees — what it actually means and why it's misunderstood

    read this FAQ

    How much the NHS will pay for a care home — and what happens when the home costs more

    read this FAQ

    NHS Continuing Healthcare and dementia — who qualifies, how to apply, and what to do if refused

    read this FAQ

    When the NHS pays for dementia care — the two situations and how to access both

    read this FAQ

    What the NHS actually covers in dementia care — and the funding most eligible families never claim

    read this FAQ
    We use cookies in order to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.
    Accept